A story-driven crime classic!
If you've played the smart and tragic ode to early 20th century organized crime movies Mafia: The City of Lost Heaven or the specific but complex muddy, bloody narrative of medieval Bohemia Kingdom Come: Deliverance, you're aware of Daniel Vavra's superb writing. His passion is clear in the story, characters, and plotting, and Mafia II is no different. The characters are complex, yet funny and familiar. Every scene feels that it could have been ripped from The Godfather, Once Upon a Time in America, or any of a number of other gangster classics. The writing of Mafia II is top tier.
The gameplay of Mafia II is a mixed bag. Driving can be a bit cumbersome (although less so than Mafia: The City of Lost Heaven where early autos were heck to drive) and gunplay isn't quite as tight as shooter fans would hope, but it's all enjoyable and wrapped in great sound effects and music. I can remember specifically one gunfight where glass was shattering and it gave the exchange a feeling I hadn't had since Black. And to the driving, Empire Bay -- although limited in interaction -- is a great, atmospheric drive. You will spend a fair amount of time behind the wheel, but the place never gets boring.
On the outside Mafia II looks like a period GTA, but it's far from it. Although you can get into trouble, beat people up, explore the world's sights, and become wanted by police, Mafia II's gameplay is tethered more closely to story than GTA. If you're going to go rogue and wander, forgetting story advancement, you'll lose interest fast. This world is atmospheric and beautiful, but the depth here is the story and not side activities or mini-games. Were there any? Mafia II's limited open world reminds me of LA Noire, a great place to cruise and listen to the radio, but if you want any meat to the gameplay, you better get back to the story (BTW, played Mafia II after LA Noire, and although I admire Rockstar, I felt Mafia II was a better all-around experience).
Having played all of the Godfather and Mafia games, this is the one I return to over-and-over -- like re-watching The Godfather on a yearly basis. Brilliantly realized, Mafia II should be in the library of anyone who enjoys games about organized crime. It's a classic.
2 gamers found this review helpful