hedwards: Well, for one thing they chose to release it as 3 separate games, which means that I was stuck playing terans rather than protoss or zerg, which was really a point against it.
Breja: It's why I still have not played beyond Wings of Liberty. I never liked playing Zerg, and the idea of paying for the Zerg campaing separately has killed my interest in the game.
Then again, truth be told, I never like StarCraft as much as Warcraft. I don't know why, it's basicall the same game in different decorations, but I never even finished the first Starcraft. I always get bored eventually, and before I ever return to it's a new PC, or I lost the hard drive or whatever, and I have to star over.
But Warcraft... hell, I've been waiting for it for years. It will be hard to kill my interest in that one. It still pisses me off that the stuff I really wanted to play through, like kicking Arthas' ass, happened without me in WoW. I always felt like WoW robbed me of something. I was there since Warcraft fucking Orcs & Humans, and suddenly the franchise got highjacked by the MMO crowd. It's about time there was a proper Warcraft for me again. I just hope I won't have to read a thousand pages of warcraft wikipedia to even know what's going on after all the WoW stuff.
I would buy WC4 if they do it right, I just don't have any confidence that they understand why those games worked. Just look at what they did to Diablo with that last one.
Granted none of the people who made those games were still working at Blizzard, but I do think that Blizzard is cashing in a bit too heavily on sequels.
I didn't care for WC3, it was a good game, but between the heroes and the other changes, it just wasn't as fun as the previous game was. WC2 was silly enough, without being too bad and there was a lot more focus on the action rather than having to level up certain units.